Sweet Secrets on Mackinac Island follows Lucy Winters, a freshly unemployed marketing executive who suddenly inherits her great-aunt’s fudge shop on Mackinac Island. What begins as a reluctant trip to tie up family business quickly spirals into an unplanned adventure. Lucy finds herself thrust into a world of quirky locals, nosy shop owners, stubborn employees, and even a judgmental cat named Felix, all while trying to learn the alchemy of fudge-making. At its core, the book blends romance, comedy, and personal reinvention against the backdrop of a magical, car-free island brimming with old-world charm.

I found myself both charmed and amused. The writing is playful without being shallow, full of little asides and sharp observations that made me laugh. Lucy’s voice felt real, not polished to perfection, which made her stumbles all the more relatable. At times, I rolled my eyes at her self-deprecating inner monologues, but I couldn’t help rooting for her. The island setting was described vividly. And the supporting characters, from Elspeth the cardigan-clad dictator of the “Fudgeamentals” to Mia with her theatrical flair, were eccentric in the best way. They gave the story texture and heart.

A few scenes stretched on longer than I thought they needed to, and sometimes the humor leaned a bit heavy on quips. But even when the story felt predictable, I didn’t mind. It was like watching a cozy rom-com. The journey is the fun. What surprised me most was how the book balanced lighthearted romance with more personal themes. Losing a job, being betrayed by a friend, trying to reinvent yourself. Those resonated with me. I caught myself nodding in recognition when Lucy questioned whether she was capable of change, because who hasn’t had that exact doubt?

Sweet Secrets on Mackinac Island is the kind of book I’d hand to a friend looking for comfort. It’s funny, a little ridiculous at times, and brimming with warmth. If you enjoy Hallmark-style stories, small-town charm, and heroines who learn to let go of their rigid plans, you’ll love this. It’s perfect for a summer read, ideally with something sweet within reach.

Pages: 306 | ASIN : B0F5NCZXTQ