Growing Up Amid Conflict

Scott Gibbs Author Interview

Toward the Turning blends philosophy, religious studies, psychology, and political analysis, arguing that conflict grows from our often-unconscious attachment to identity systems. Why was this an important book for you to write?

For as long as I can remember, conflict has felt dangerous to me because of how quickly it can spiral and leave people hurt. Growing up amid conflict at home and in a city (Flint, MI) marked by poverty and racial tension taught me early that conflict cannot be understood apart from the conditions in which it arises. I also found that I could see competing perspectives and help people navigate differences more constructively. Shortly after 9/11, writing this book began to feel like something I was supposed to do. Ambition was part of it early on, but gradually receded. The mission became less about producing a successful book than about faithfully developing its argument, getting it right, and bringing it into the world for greater human harmony. Over time, the work itself mattered far more than any recognition attached to it.

Why did this subject require such an interdisciplinary approach?

I began with a simple question: Why did 9/11 happen? Each answer only deepened the question. Because conflict is relational, the inquiry moved across the interacting worlds of the West and Islam. It also moved downward, from historical events, rhetoric, and grievances—the immediate causes and stated reasons for the conflict—to their psychological and identity-based roots. Seeking the ground beneath those forces, it finally reached the most basic structures of human existence and the domain of the philosophical. The interdisciplinary approach was necessary, then, to connect the particular forces that converged in 9/11 with the deeper conditions that made this kind of conflict possible.

You argue that modernity creates both freedom and anxiety. Why do you think those two outcomes are so closely connected?

Modernity frees us from inherited authorities and limits (e.g., religious institutions and dogma, kings and tradition) and empowers us through reason, science, and individual agency to understand and reshape the world. But removing the foundations those authorities provided leaves us without ultimate authorities and abandons us to judge, choose, and bear the consequences alone, without certainty. In this sense, then, freedom and anxiety therefore walk together. The further irony is that modernity’s instruments of liberation—control, individuality, and progress—have become new masters.

Has writing this book changed the way you approach conflict in your own life?

My work as a couples counselor and writing this book have deeply informed each other regarding conflict. Together, they led me to see it less as fixed perpetrators and victims and more as a system and iterative process, with each action answering what came before and shaping what follows. I watch for closed-mindedness and rigidity, and try to meet them with openness and flexibility. In communication, I watch for blame, defensiveness, and contempt, especially in myself, and try to meet them with owning my own experience, curiosity, and respect. I listen for what each person is saying, consciously and implicitly, what feels threatened, and what they are protecting and seeking. Skeptical of adversarial debate and wary of repetitive drama, I pursue dialogue, seeking collaboration rather than competition.  I try to understand what problem we are solving, what my response is likely to evoke next, and which differences must be negotiated rather than eliminated. I still get caught, which keeps me in my place about how difficult this is.

Author Links: Amazon | GoodReads

The ultimate source of group inhumanity is an apparition, spectacularly unrecognized and ignored. While we scapegoat tribalism and fanaticism, those impulses are merely derivatives of a deeper engine of recruitment: our unwitting loyalty to inherited identities. Toward the Turning exposes this engine, revealing how it fractures and inflames human relations. Using 9/11 and the “War on Terror” collision of Islamic, Zionist, and Western identities as its touchstone, the book reframes global division not as good-versus-evil, but as a theater of the absurd defined by “deadly dances” fueled by identity-in-difference. These identity systems function as tacit, communal compacts through which we navigate existential groundlessness. They constitute us, but they also destroy us. At their core lies an ontological misapprehension: We see the self as a discrete “thing” and the world as an external, given backdrop, blind to their contingency and co-constituting processes. This error underwrites the naturalization of identity, making it susceptible to the tribal fanaticism that haunts history. Scott Gibbs’ fascinating monograph culminates in a call for a “turning”―not toward a new ideology, but a corrective understanding that can move us beyond violent, reactive patterns. When groundlessness becomes habitable, the grip of identity loosens, difference becomes negotiable, and the compulsion to control subsides.
Unknown's avatar

About Literary Titan

The Literary Titan is an organization of professional editors, writers, and professors that have a passion for the written word. We review fiction and non-fiction books in many different genres, as well as conduct author interviews, and recognize talented authors with our Literary Book Award. We are privileged to work with so many creative authors around the globe.

Posted on August 4, 2026, in Interviews and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. Leave a comment.

Leave a Reply