Blog Archives

Honesty is a Virtue

Erin Miller Reid Author Interview

But for Fortune follows a Kentucky medical student whose search for the truth about her institutionalized grandmother exposes the betrayals, medical injustices, and enduring music that bind their lives across generations. What was the inspiration for the setup of your story?

The story stems from my own experience as a medical student doing a month-long psychiatry rotation at Eastern State Hospital, where my grandmother had been a patient from the 1950s-1990s. Like Corinth in the novel, I couldn’t help but wonder what life had been like for my grandmother in that place, and I was struck by the coincidence that both my grandmother and I had arrived at the same place at roughly the same age, but for very different reasons.

Though the story is rooted in a real-life experience, I feel more adept at finding truth through fiction rather than nonfiction. When writing, I am more comfortable making up a story than sticking to a story, so choosing to write a novel with fictional characters in fictional situations was straightforward.

How did you balance the clinical realities of depression and medical hierarchy with the novel’s more lyrical elements, particularly music, nature, and faith?

As a physician and a writer, the clinical and the lyrical are a daily reality and are equally important to me. In fact, I relish moments when I can blend the two rather than hold them in counterbalance. I see beauty in physiology and anatomy and metaphor in disease. Nature is aesthetically beautiful, but also innately scientific. Music is not only an essential form of human expression but also relies on concepts found in math and physics, and faith, whether its faith in a higher power or faith in a shared humanity, is simply a fact of being human. To me, it’s the yin and yang between the clinical and lyrical that breed interest and complexity and lead me to explore a character’s motivations and experiences on a deeper level.

Mary Esther uses numbers, trees, piano music, and scripture to make sense of her world. How did you develop these recurring motifs as expressions of her interior life?

Mary Esther’s character is based on my own grandmother. Unfortunately, I only know snippets of my grandmother’s past. By the time I was born, her brain had been addled by years of institutionalization and outdated psychiatric drugs and treatments. She was unable to tell me about herself. That lack of knowledge gave me a lot of freedom to create the character of Mary Esther without being tempted to include too much of my non-fictional grandmother in the character. However, there are a few things I knew about my grandmother that I wanted to include as a way to honor her history. She played piano and she was an excellent student (hence the fascination with numbers). She was also devout in her faith, and, I imagine when she was well, my grandmother would have recited scripture from memory as Mary Esther does throughout the book.

Trees act as characters in the novel: They’re studied, they’re revered, and, in some instances, they speak. My admiration for trees made their inclusion in the story a natural, unquestioned choice. Trees fascinate me. They offer shelter, shade, and food. They are beautiful to look at, from exposed roots to the ragged bark of their trunks to their variegated leaves and flowering blooms. They are also wise. I like to imagine all that a towering, aged tree has witnessed, what it could tell me if it spoke in a language I understood.

What do you hope readers will reconsider about inherited trauma, family silence, and the act of witnessing after finishing your book?

My novel centers honesty as a virtue. Honesty is necessary. Honesty leads to understanding. It fosters empathy. When we inherit and then perpetuate secrets, we only limit the ability to process traumatic experiences. The act of sharing our stories, the secrets, through fiction or nonfiction is an act of bearing witness, and by bearing witness, we open the door to discernment, connection, and appreciation for the inherited histories that have formed us.

Author Website

On the surface, Corinth Eaton’s life is going according to plan. She is succeeding in her third year of medical school and in a serious relationship with a man she intends to marry. In reality, Corinth is barely afloat, struggling with debilitating anxiety and depression, as well as the recent death of her father. A split-second decision results in her suspension from surgery rotation and reassignment to Maxwood, the state psychiatric institution where her grandmother was a patient for decades. When Corinth discovers Granny’s chart at Maxwood, she’s desperate to make sense of the narrative in its pages―events her family refuses to discuss. Corinth had only ever known Granny as docile and incoherent from years of medication and institutionalization, unable to provide her own account. But Corinth’s rotation at Maxwood might just allow her to connect with her grandmother in ways she couldn’t before.

But For Fortune

In But for Fortune by Erin Miller Reid, two women’s lives braid across time: Corinth, a Kentucky medical student in 2000 staggering under depression, professional scrutiny, and personal betrayal; and Mary Esther, her grandmother, whose youth in mid-century Appalachia is slowly revealed through poverty, marriage, motherhood, institutionalization, and the music that survives every attempt to silence her. The novel moves like a double helix, each woman’s story illuminating the other until family history becomes less an inheritance than a living wound—and, finally, a form of witness.

I was pulled in by the book’s refusal to make suffering tidy. Corinth’s medical training is rendered with the bracing intimacy of someone who knows both the body and the hierarchy that governs it: cadaver labs, operating rooms, single-stall bathrooms where panic can be privately metabolized. Her depression isn’t dramatized as decorative gloom; it is chemical, situational, humiliating, and exhausting. Reid writes the hospital world with an unsentimental eye, but she also finds strange beauty there, the anatomy of grief, the ache of competence, the moral peril of silence.

Mary Esther’s chapters give the novel its deepest ache. Her story could have become a familiar tale of rural hardship and institutional cruelty, but Reid gives her interior life a fierce, exacting dignity. Numbers, trees, piano music, and scripture become the language of a girl trying to make order in a world determined to misread her. The novel’s structure is especially effective: as Corinth investigates what happened to her grandmother, the past doesn’t simply “explain” the present. It unsettles it. It asks what families bury, what medicine once sanctioned, and what remains in a person after almost everything has been taken.

This book will speak to readers of literary fiction, historical fiction, and multigenerational family drama. Its interwoven timelines and excavation of women’s hidden lives reminded me of The Vanishing Half by Brit Bennett, though Reid’s voice is earthier, more clinical, and more steeped in the mountain South. But for Fortune is a tender, scalpel-sharp novel about damage, memory, and the stubborn music that outlives erasure.

Pages: 320 | ISBN: 1985904780

Buy Now From Amazon