Blog Archives

Restorative Justice and Alternative Sentencing

Shari Lane Author Interview

Two Over Easy All Day Long follows the president of a toy company who is found guilty of negligence and sentenced to a year working for minimum wage in a remote diner in Oregon. What inspired the setup of your story?

My personal history had a significant influence on the story. I practiced bankruptcy law for a year, and employment law for sixteen years, including a stint with the Oregon Bureau of Labor & Industries enforcing civil rights laws in the workplace; I was on the board of a Head Start organization serving primarily the children of migrant and seasonal farmworkers; I was part of an organization partnering with the Oregon Food Bank; and I served as an arbitrator for court-ordered arbitration (which usually involved debt-collection from a defendant who had little or no ability to pay). In other words, I had a bird’s-eye view of both the power and the impotence of our legal system, and some of the consequences of income inequality.

When I started writing this book, about ten years ago, there was a lot of talk about restorative justice, and alternative sentencing, and I heard that some judges, given any leeway at all, were exploring these ideas in their sentencing. Interestingly (to me, at least!), there was recently an example of a situation very similar to the story in Two Over Easy All Day Long. Maybe you remember the December 2023 sentencing of a woman who threw her food at a server in a Chipotle restaurant—because she was unhappy with the food. The (marvelously named) Judge Gilligan sentenced her to jail but offered to waive some of the time “if she agreed to work at least 20 hours per week at a fast-food restaurant for two months.” When the defendant tried to justify her actions by pointing out the food “was disgusting looking,” the judge said, “I bet you won’t be happy with the food you are going to get in the jail.” (Source: “Woman Who Assaulted Chipotle Worker Sentenced to Fast Food Job for Two Months,” BBC, December 6, 2023. Accessed April 22, 2024).

The other more “mystical” explanation (for lack of a better word) is that often characters seem to present themselves to me with a stern, “Take this down, scribe,” and that is what happened with Tony, Walt, Nancy, Leesa, and Nareen. There are moments when they seem more real to me than the actual humans in my life. I can’t decide if that’s the workings of a mystical muse or if I’m teetering on the edge of sanity. I’ll let you know when I figure it out.

Your characters are diverse and well-developed, giving readers someone to relate to. What are some things that you find interesting about the human condition that you think make for great fiction?

I find it fascinating that we have to keep re-learning the same basic life lessons. We learn we shouldn’t act in haste, we learn we should seek help when life gets overwhelming . . . and then we screw up, and have to start all over re-discovering basic truths about ourselves. When I think how often I’ve cried “Eureka!,” joyously declaring I’ve escaped my past, my unhealthy patterns, and then realize I’ve ended up in the same old mess, it’s distressing. And it’s an endless source of writing material. A related idea is the possibility of redemption. Even after diving off a cliff, (metaphorically) crashing and burning in the ravine below, it’s possible to emerge from the flames, phoenix-like, a new creature.

What were some themes that were important for you to explore in this book?

The most important theme for me is not alternative justice or income inequality – though both are important to the story – it is the healing power of friendship and community, and the idea that so many of our bitter divisions can be bridged by sharing our lives and our stories with each other. The old maxim instructing us to “walk a mile in another man’s shoes” (which I, of course, would change to “another person’s shoes”) holds deep truth.

What is the next book that you are working on, and when will it be available?

So many works-in-progress!

I am working on a sequel to Two Over Easy All Day Long, working title: Redemption at Sunnyside Up.

I am seeking representation for Jaysus, MooMoo, and the Immortal Woos (which was recently longlisted in the 2024 international Stockholm Writers Festival First Five Pages contest).

In 2022 I self-published an online serialized novel called What the Dogs Know. I took the novel down from the website in anticipation of publication of a physical copy of the entire work, but the first chapter is still available at www.alaughingdog.com. I am working on the prequel (Who Laughs Last) and the sequel (What You Need), both loosely based on life in the San Juan Islands in Northwestern Washington (where I live). One or both of those should be out in the next year or so.

Author Links: GoodReads | Facebook | Website | Amazon

Giles Anthony Maurice Gibson, Manhattanite and president of ABC Toys, floats through life on a cloud of wealth and privilege. Until now. When his company’s negligence results in tragedy, the judge, weary of a world where justice is rarely served, sentences Giles to a year of community service in rural Oregon, and supervised work at Sunnyside Up, a local diner. Renamed “Tony,” and fitted with an ankle monitor to keep him in his place, he must find a way to make amends for the consequences of always choosing the easy way.

Shortly after Giles-learning-to-be-Tony arrives, the curmudgeonly cook finds a dead body in the dumpster behind the restaurant. Tony and the other misfits at the diner are soon suspects, but—though they will eventually work together to figure out “whodunnit”—Two Over Easy All Day Long isn’t a murder mystery, it’s a human mystery, asking how far a person can bend before breaking, and whether breaking isn’t the point, after all.

Two Over Easy All Day Long

Two Over Easy All Day Long, by Shari Lane, is a compelling fiction story that follows the journey of Giles Anthony Gibson, the president of ABC (America’s Best Company) Toys in New York City. Inheriting the business from his father, Tony’s life takes a dramatic turn when a child tragically chokes on one of ABC’s toys, leading to Tony being sentenced to a year of community service in the small town of Motte and Bailey, Oregon. There, he is forced to work a minimum wage job at the Sunnyside Up diner as part of his reparation for negligence. As Tony grapples with his new reality, his journey takes an unexpected twist when a dead body is discovered in the diner’s dumpster, thrusting him into an unforeseen and harrowing situation.

The narrative captivates with its richly drawn characters who work at the Sunnyside Up diner. The diverse and colorful cast of employees forms a tight-knit community, providing mutual support and camaraderie through various challenges. The long-time employees’ warm acceptance of newcomers, including Tony, adds depth to the story, highlighting the power of community and belonging. Each character’s backstory and path to the diner are thoughtfully explored, enriching the overall narrative. Tony’s character arc is particularly engaging. Initially portrayed as passive and directionless, his experiences in Motte and Bailey gradually transform him. He stumbles through numerous missteps but ultimately learns valuable lessons about himself and others from different walks of life. This personal growth is a testament to the profound impact of his time in Oregon, offering him a renewed perspective that extends beyond his year of service.

While the book predominantly employs third-person past tense from Tony’s viewpoint, several sections intriguingly switch to third-person present tense, each titled with egg names rather than traditional chapter numbers. This narrative choice, though unconventional, adds a unique flavor to the storytelling, although its purpose may not be immediately clear to all readers.

One intriguing aspect of the plot is Tony’s unexpected decision to become involved in a cover-up rather than reporting a crucial discovery. This surprising twist adds complexity to his character, presenting a challenging scenario that pushes him to confront his moral boundaries. While this action diverges from the straightforward path of redemption, it introduces a layer of tension and growth, ultimately enriching his journey and highlighting the nuances of his transformation.

Two Over Easy All Day Long is a thought-provoking and heartwarming read that explores themes of accountability, personal growth, and the power of community. Shari Lane’s storytelling offers a vivid and engaging experience, despite a few narrative choices that may not resonate with every reader.

Pages: 286 | ASIN : B0D1ZMPL9J

Buy Now From Amazon